Mexico’s state-run oil company, Petroleos Mexicanos (Pemex), has faced longstanding criticism for its safety practices. Despite pledging to eliminate worker fatalities in 2024, Pemex has already suffered multiple fatal incidents this year, leading to at least six deaths and dozens of injuries. These tragic events have highlighted systemic failures in safety protocols, inadequate infrastructure investment, and a corporate culture prioritizing cost-cutting over worker welfare.
In the article below, the oil and gas injury lawyers at Kherkher Garcia delve into the series of accidents, the legal implications for Pemex, and the broader concerns over the company’s operations and accountability. Anyone with questions about an oil and gas injury can contact Kherkher Garcia directly to learn more.
Pemex’s Pledge and Its Troubled History
At the beginning of 2024, Pemex made an ambitious promise: “No more fatalities.” This pledge aimed to address the company’s alarming safety record, which includes decades of fatal accidents and preventable disasters.
Despite its zero-fatality goal, Pemex’s track record reflects a failure to address deep-rooted safety issues. For example, Pemex has long been the leader among its peers in worker fatalities. Its operations have been plagued by insufficient safety inspections, aging infrastructure, and a chronic lack of investment in preventative measures. In 2020, Pemex also made headlines for reporting more COVID-related worker deaths than any other company globally.
These factors have contributed to frequent industrial accidents, many of which result in serious injuries or deaths.
A String of Deadly Incidents in 2024
Despite their pledge, Pemex facilities have seen numerous incidents in 2024. Some of the most notable examples include the following:
Explosion at Offshore Platform
Just weeks after Pemex announced its zero-fatality pledge, an explosion occurred at an offshore oil platform. The incident killed one worker and injured nine others, underscoring Pemex’s inability to implement meaningful safety measures in its high-risk operations.
Refinery Fire in Salina Cruz
Five months later, a fire broke out at the Salina Cruz refinery, one of Pemex’s largest facilities. Overflowing storm drains containing oily runoff ignited, causing a blaze that killed two contractors. The incident revealed glaring deficiencies in infrastructure maintenance and emergency response protocols.
Deadly Chemical Leak in the U.S.
In October, a chemical leak at Pemex’s Deer Park refinery in Texas led to the deaths of two contractors and sent 13 others to the hospital. The leak involved hydrogen sulfide gas, a highly toxic substance, and marked the largest such release in Texas in a decade. Investigations revealed that Pemex failed to adhere to its own safety protocols, including leaving a critical valve unlocked and delaying emergency notifications to responders.
Fuel Truck Accident Near Mexico City
In November, another tragedy occurred when a Pemex fuel truck was involved in a fatal accident near Mexico City, killing one person. This incident further emphasized the systemic safety issues within Pemex’s operations.
Legal Ramifications for Pemex
Pemex incidents not only represent numerous injuries and loss of life, but also serious legal consequences for the company. Below are some of the most serious inquiries and issues the company is facing in the wake of an injurious 2024:
U.S. Litigation and Federal Investigations
The Deer Park refinery accident has triggered multiple lawsuits and federal investigations. Injured workers allege that Pemex violated safety standards by failing to secure equipment properly and neglecting its alarm systems. Attorneys representing the victims claim that these lapses created a chaotic and life-threatening situation during the leak.
Federal agencies, including the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board (CSB), Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), and the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), are probing the incident. Preliminary findings suggest multiple levels of failure, from prevention to emergency response, which could result in significant penalties for Pemex.
Insurance Coverage Issues
Pemex’s safety failures have also strained its relationships with insurers. Following the Deer Park incident, some Mexican insurers temporarily suspended coverage for Pemex, citing concerns about the company’s industrial safety practices. Internal documents reveal that insurers demanded a review of Pemex’s safety strategy and threatened to withdraw policies if improvements were not made.
While Pemex has maintained sufficient coverage for its Deer Park operations, gaps in insurance for its other facilities could expose the company to significant financial liability in the event of future accidents.
Financial Pressures and Safety Challenges
Pemex’s inability to invest in safety improvements stems from its dire financial situation. With approximately $97 billion in debt, Pemex is the world’s most indebted oil company. While the Mexican government provides periodic cash infusions to keep the company afloat, these funds are insufficient to address the root causes of Pemex’s safety problems.
Experts estimate that Pemex needs substantial investment to modernize its facilities and reduce the risk of accidents. However, the company’s financial constraints make such investments unlikely. Instead, Pemex has focused on short-term cost-cutting measures that have inadvertently increased safety risks.
Pemex’s safety record and financial instability have alarmed investors, particularly those with environmental, social, and governance (ESG) mandates. The company’s failure to meet its zero-fatality target undermines its credibility and could deter U.S. and European investors from providing capital. This lack of investor confidence may further complicate Pemex’s efforts to refinance its debt.
Systemic Safety Failures
Despite Pemex’s public commitment to improving worker safety, the company’s operations remain plagued by systemic failures that jeopardize the lives of employees and contractors. From outdated infrastructure to a culture that prioritizes cost-cutting over compliance, these deeply rooted issues have contributed to a series of preventable disasters.
Culture of Cost-Cutting
Industry experts and Pemex employees have pointed to a corporate culture that prioritizes cost-cutting over safety. For instance, the 2023 offshore explosion was linked to Pemex hiring a contractor, Cotemar, that underbid competitors by promising to complete safety inspections in half the usual time. Such practices increase the likelihood of equipment failures and accidents.
Inadequate Emergency Responses
Pemex’s emergency response systems have repeatedly failed during critical incidents. At Deer Park, the company delayed activating its emergency notification system, which hindered first responders and exposed nearby communities to additional risks. Local officials also criticized Pemex for providing misleading information, such as labeling the incident as “routine flaring.”
Outdated Infrastructure
Many of Pemex’s facilities rely on aging equipment that has not been adequately maintained or upgraded. For example, the Salina Cruz refinery fire was exacerbated by poor stormwater management and outdated drainage systems. Without significant infrastructure investment, similar incidents are likely to occur.
Each incident underscores the urgent need for structural reform, yet Pemex continues to struggle with implementing meaningful safety protocols.
Broader Implications
Pemex’s safety failures have profound consequences for its workers and the communities surrounding its facilities. The loss of life and injuries sustained in these accidents are compounded by long-term health risks, such as exposure to toxic substances like hydrogen sulfide gas.
For affected workers and their families, seeking justice can be an uphill battle, particularly in Mexico, where corporate accountability mechanisms are weaker than in the U.S.
The involvement of U.S. facilities in Pemex’s accidents has drawn international attention to the company’s safety practices. Federal investigations and lawsuits in the U.S. are likely to uncover details that would remain opaque in Mexico, increasing pressure on Pemex to improve its operations.
What Can Be Done?
The ongoing safety crises at Pemex have highlighted the urgent need for actionable solutions to protect workers, surrounding communities, and the environment. Addressing these systemic issues requires more than promises or reactive measures; it demands changes in the following areas:
Strengthening Safety Protocols
Pemex must prioritize the development and enforcement of robust safety protocols across all its facilities. This includes comprehensive training for workers, regular equipment inspections, and adherence to industry standards.
Increasing Transparency
Improving transparency is essential for rebuilding trust with investors, insurers, and regulators. Pemex should publicly disclose the findings of safety investigations and outline concrete steps to prevent future accidents.
Investing in Infrastructure
To reduce the risk of accidents, Pemex must invest in modernizing its aging facilities. While this will require significant financial resources, the long-term benefits far outweigh the costs associated with repeated safety failures.
Holding Management Accountable
Accountability at the management level is crucial for driving meaningful change. Pemex’s leadership must be held responsible for failing to meet safety targets and ensuring worker welfare.
Pemex’s failure to uphold its 2024 zero-fatality pledge has exposed systemic issues within the company, from inadequate safety protocols to chronic underinvestment. The tragic deaths of at least six workers this year serve as a stark reminder of the human cost of these failures. For its workers, investors, and the communities it serves, Pemex’s ability to implement meaningful reforms will determine whether it can rebuild trust and operate safely in the future.
What to Do After a Pemex Incident, Injury, or Death
If you or a loved one has been injured or killed in an incident involving Pemex, taking immediate action is critical to protect your rights. These accidents often result from systemic safety failures, and victims deserve justice for the harm they’ve suffered. At Kherkher Garcia, we are dedicated to helping victims and their families navigate the legal complexities of oil and gas industry claims.
Here’s what you can do to take the first step toward justice:
- Seek Medical Attention: Your health and safety are the priority. Ensure you or your loved one receives proper medical care and retain records of all treatments and diagnoses.
- Document the Incident: Collect evidence, including photos, witness statements, and any communications regarding the incident. This documentation can be crucial for your case.
- Contact an Attorney: Industry-related claims are complex, involving powerful companies and intricate legal issues. Our experienced attorneys will investigate the incident, identify liable parties, and fight for the compensation you deserve.
At Kherkher Garcia, we have a proven track record of holding negligent corporations accountable. Let us help you secure the financial recovery you need to rebuild your life.
Contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case and explore your legal options. You don’t have to face this alone – our team is here to help every step of the way. Get started right now by calling us at 713-333-1030. You can also reach out to us via our online contact form.
Resources:
